Calculating STI

Prev Next

IR Measurement Considerations for STI

Smaart can calculate Speech Transmission Index (STI) indirectly from an Impulse Response (IR) measurement provided that certain conditions are met. In general, there are several "moving parts" one needs to keep in mind when performing STI or STIPA measurements using any methodology. Ambient noise levels and the operational speech level of the system under test (SUT) are important factors in obtaining accurate estimations of intelligibility. For systems that include a live microphone, the microphone and its acoustical environment along with the acoustical properties of the sound source used to excite the SUT are also important considerations, regardless of the measurement technique.

For indirect measurements specifically, where the Modulation Transfer Function (MTF) of the SUT is derived from an impulse response rather than measured directly using specialized test signals, additional requirements are:

  • A deterministic test Signal (period-matched noise or log sweep) must be used without a data window to measure the IR.

  • The measurement duration (the FFT Time Constant in our case), per IEC 60268-16:2020, must be at least 1.6 seconds.

The latter requirement, however, seems to overlook an important property of Fourier analysis using linearly spaced frequencies.

It is true that a conventional Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) (or FFT) with a 1.59 second time constant would have its first (non-zero) frequency bin at 0.63 Hz (the lowest modulation frequency evaluated in the MTF for STI). But since FFT bins are linearly spaced, the second bin is always an octave above the first, whereas modulation frequencies for STI are on 1/3-octave center frequencies. Calculating STI from a 1.6 second IR measurement would therefore require somehow interpolating the missing frequencies in the lowest octaves, and the standard does not address that requirement. Another option would be to simply measure over a longer period. A 5-second DFT time constant, for example, would provide frequency resolution of 0.2 Hz, resulting in frequency bins very close to all of the STI modulation frequencies. For this reason, Smaart offers a DFT size equating to exactly 5 seconds (5000 ms) for all supported sampling rates ≥ 44100 samples/sec.

Calculating STI from an IR

To calculate STI from an impulse response measurement, make sure the IR measurement that you want to analyze – whether it is a new measurement or an IR stored in a .wav file – is visible in the graph in the main window and is the front trace on the graph (at the top of the list in the Graph Legend) if multiple traces are displayed. Click the All Bands button at the bottom of the Control Bar to open the All Bands table and then click the Calculate STI button in the All Bands Table to open the Calculate STI dialog.

The first thing you will need to tell Smaart is whether the measurement is “Noiseless” or made in the presence of normal ambient background noise levels (Noise Present).

  • Noise present measurements require the use of a period-matched, speech-weighted noise signal when capturing the IR. They are measured at the operational sound level of the system, without averaging, in the presence of typical in-service ambient noise levels. The measurement signal input for the transfer function signal pair used to capture the IR measurement must be calibrated for accurate sound level measurement.

  • Noiseless measurements are typically made during quiet times, when ambient noise levels are lower than they would normally be when the system is in use and/or at a higher output level than the normal operating level of the SUT. They require separate estimation of operational speech level and typical in-service ambient noise levels. IR measurements can be made using period-matched Pink Noise exponential sweeps (a.k.a., log sweeps or “pink” sweeps). The signal-to-noise ratio in each octave band from 125 Hz to 8 kHz must be at least 20 dB. IR measurements may be averaged to improve the signal-to-noise ratio.

Selecting Noise Present is fairly automatic, so long as the IR measurement being analyzed was captured:

  • Using Smaart 8.5 or later,

  • With a calibrated measurement signal input, and

  • With no averaging.

Once Noise Present is selected, Smaart calculates sound level for the measurement channel while capturing the IR and it is assumed that typical ambient noise levels are included in the measurement. STI, STIPA(IR), and equivalent CIS figures along with overall qualitative assessment (Excellent, Good, Fair, or Poor) and letter grades appear in the Results section of the dialog window.

For Noiseless measurements, you first need to provide the operational Speech Level for the SUT as an A-weighed sound level figure. You will also need unweighted (Lz) noise levels for each octave band that are typical of ambient noise levels present when the system is in normal use. The latter can be imported from a calibrated Smaart RTA measurement by clicking the Import Noise button and selecting the appropriate .srf file, or by manually entering Decibel levels for each octave directly into the table's Noise dB row. You also have the option to estimate the effect of equalization on the STI figure by entering +/- dB values in the EQ dB row of the table. Values in the Results section will update as you make changes.

The Clear EQ and Clear Noise buttons reset the corresponding rows of the table to all zeroes.

The Copy button copies MTI, EQ, and Noise values from the table along with the MTF “m” values for all modulation frequencies in all octaves to the operating system's clipboard in tab-delimited ASCII format, suitable for pasting into a spreadsheet, text file, or any other program that accepts ASCII text.

When you have made your selections you can save your work by clicking the Save button. If you are working with a new live measurement, Smaart will prompt you for a file name and then write the IR measurement to a .wav file with the STI calculation details included as metadata in the file header. If you are working with an IR measurement already stored in a .wav file, Smaart will rewrite the file with a new header that includes the STI metadata. In that case, you will be asked to confirm that you want to over-write the existing file.

Note that the audio sample data in an existing .wav file is untouched when you save STI calculation details, but some programs (particularly older or very basic audio editing/analysis software) may be unable to open the file after saving it.

Smaart 8.5 (or later) uses the BWAV header specification for IR data files, which most modern (and probably some not-so-modern) software that works with audio files should be able to parse but it is a good idea to test that assumption before overwriting your only copy of a file created by another program (including older versions of Smaart).