Single and Dual-Channel Measurement Techniques

Prev Next

In real-time mode, Smaart performs two basic types of Domain measurements: single-channel (Signal analysis) and dual-channel (response analysis).

Single-channel Spectrum measurements are signal analysis measurements; all they can tell you is the frequency content and Amplitude of a signal. Real-time spectrum analyzer (RTA) and Spectrograph displays are based on single-channel FFT analysis.

Another example would be sound level measurements, i.e., Sound Pressure Level (SPL) or equivalent sound level (Leq). When calibrated to an absolute reference such as SPL, single-channel measurements give you absolute values that are directly comparable to other absolute values and tell you exactly how loud a sound is at a given frequency, or across a given frequency range. They can help to answer questions such as, “How much 1 kHz energy is in that signal,” “What is the frequency of that tone,” or “What is the SPL at this location in the venue?”

Dual-channel measurements compare two signals to find the similarities and differences between them. Transfer Function and Impulse Response measurements in Smaart are dual-channel measurements that compare the output of a device or system to the input signal that produced it. We can therefore say that we are measuring the response of the system to a given stimulus, and because both signals are known, the spectrum of the input signal becomes almost immaterial. We are also able to precisely measure time relationships between the two signals, enabling us to examine Phase relationships and find delay times.

Single-channel vs dual-channel measurements.

Dual-channel methods provide a relative measurement (input vs. output), and can help to answer questions like “What is the crossover frequency in our system,” “How much boost or Attenuation is there at 1 kHz,” or “When is energy from my main speaker system arriving at the measurement mic?”

Both single- and dual-channel measurement can be powerful tools when you understand their individual strengths and weaknesses – what they are measuring, and just as importantly, what they are not. Confusing or conflating the two, however, can lead to poor decisions based on incomplete or incorrect information.


Real-Time Analyzers/RTA (Smaart RT, LE, Suite, Smaart RTA on Mobile)

A Real-Time Analyzer is possibly the simplest measurement method. It takes a signal and breaks it down mathematically by frequency, then displays the frequency content of that signal.

This is done via what is effectively a series of bandpass filters with level meters. Digitally, the data comes from an FFT, or Fast Fourier Transform (a mathematical operation that breaks a signal down into its individual frequencies) and is then banded into octaves or fractional octaves.

Spectrum data is most often banded into 1/3 octave bands and viewed on a Logarithmic Scale. Smaart offers higher resolution options including 1/6, 1/12, 1/24, and 1/48 octave. Octave banding is another commonly utilized option, although it offers the lowest resolution. If we band the entire spectrum together, we have a regular signal level meter. In fact, that's a good way to think of the RTA - having a bunch of level meters for different frequency ranges. More information on banding can be found here.

Smaart also has different options for averaging, other wise known as integration time. The higher the averaging value, the less "jumpy" the meters get. This can help produce a clearer picture of the signal's tonal balance as we view it over time.

Being a single-channel measurement type, an RTA only displays information contained within the signal itself. It is unable to account for any processing or time-related information. It is frequently used in order to visualize the tonal balance of a mix.


Spectrograph (Smaart RT, LE, Suite, Smaart RTA on Mobile)

If we were to view an RTA measurement "from above" over time, we can gain valuable insight into how the measured signal can change from moment to moment. This can provide context, especially when measuring a dynamic signal such as music.

As shown in this screenshot, brighter colors correspond to higher levels. Utilizing a spectrograph, it is easy to spot feedback and ringing, as well as trends in frequency over time.

If we view a series of RTA measurements back-to-back, we can get a better context on how the signal's levels change over time at specific frequencies. Here's a split view showing an RTA below and a spectrograph above. In a spectrograph, brighter colors correspond to higher levels. This dual view is a big help when keeping track of mixing decisions. It's also the easiest way to spot feedback and ringing in a system. It can prove difficult on a simple RTA because once an obvious peak forms, it's likely very audibly loud in the room. The spectrograph can reveal a trend of ringing over time as a bright (high-level) vertical line.


Transfer Function/Dual-Channel FFT (Smaart RT, LE, Suite)

A Transfer Function (or dual-channel FFT) shows the difference between two signals. As such, comparing a signal to itself via loopback or other method will result in a flat Magnitude response. Any stimulus type can be used for a dual-channel Transfer Function measurement, but random or pseudorandom noise signals are the most common. (More information on noise types and contours can be found here)

It's possible to take several real-time measurements within a couple of seconds for averaging purposes, which can help with noise reduction. A Coherence metric compares the correlation of the measurement and reference signals as a percentage. More information pertaining to coherence in Smaart can be found here. This is helpful for spotting noise, reverberant energy, reflections, and other auditory phenomena that can lead to inaccurate measurements.

The end result is that we can measure more quickly and at a lower-level using our choice of program material, so a dual-channel system is probably the friendliest choice for working on a system when other stuff is happening around us (both for us and for them).


Impulse Response Measurement (Smaart Suite Only)

Impulse Response Measurements are a special exception, as they can be performed either single-channel (Direct) or dual-channel (Indirect).

Direct IR Measurement

The most intuitive way to measure the impulse response of a system is to simply use an impulsive stimulus and record what happens. To do so, you don't need a sound system or even a measurement system to perform the measurement, which is certainly convenient. You just need a way to make a short, loud sound and a way to record it.

The main issue with this approach is twofold:

  • It doesn't tell you anything about an installed sound system (if applicable).

  • There is a scarcity of effective impulsive stimulus sources.

The ideal impulsive stimulus would be a perfectly instantaneous, perfectly omnidirectional burst of energy with equal energy at all audible frequencies. In the time Domain, it would appear as a single vertical spike no more than one sample in width. In the frequency domain, it would produce perfectly flat Magnitude and Phase traces. Any changes to its "flat" response would be visually apparent, making it a blank canvas against which to view any nonlinearities. In physics, this is known as a Dirac pulse. Unfortunately, such a stimulus signal does not exist in the physical world.

When directly measuring the impulse response of an acoustical system, our options are limited to less-than-ideal stimulus sources. Blank pistols and balloon pops have been commonly used, as well as signal cannon, spark gaps, fireworks and even spot welders.

Problems with these excitation sources include these:

  • Their spectral content is not uniform.

  • Their envelopes are not instantaneous.

  • They aren't as omnidirectional as they may seem.

These factors vary from one measurement to the next, limiting repeatability. Additionally, the unpredictability of these factors creates uncertainty as to which part of the completed measurement is stimulus and which is response. For this reason, indirect measurement systems infer the response of a system using an ideal impulse and are much more commonly used.

Indirect IR Measurement

Indirect impulse response measurements are made using dual-channel measurement techniques that mathematically estimate the response of an SUT by using either continuous or periodic test signals. These measurement systems calculate the frequency-domain Transfer Function of a system under test (SUT) by comparing the signal going into a system to the output of the system in response to said input.

When creating the transfer function of a stimulus signal and the SUT's response to it, it strongly resembles an ideal impulse. This is roughly what happens when you use a pseudorandom, period-matched excitation signal. Alternatively, using random signals for this purpose can lead to extra noise. This can be circumvented, however, by repeating the measurement several times and averaging the results will serve to lower the noise floor, a simple feat for Smaart.


Time Delay Spectrometry/TDS (Not Present in Smaart)

Smaart is a real-time measurement tool and cannot perform Time Delay Spectrometry measurement (although Sweep is a Signal Generator option). To perform TDS measurement would require another measurement engine entirely.

Time Delay Spectrometry (TDS) is a dual-channel measurement method that utilizes a sine wave "sweep" as its test signal. This signal "sweeps" at a steady rate from the low end of the frequency spectrum upwards towards the high end. While this sweep originally ascended at a linear rate, current methodology instead utilizes a logarithmic sweep, like you'd see from Smaart's signal generator. As such, it is commonly referred to as a "pink sweep" or a "swept" measurement.

Being a sine wave, only one frequency is passing through the system at any given point in time. As such, capturing the system response at any given moment during the sweep will show the system response at that specific frequency, in isolation. This allows for the visualization of any potential harmonic distortion caused by the system.

Note: Smaart is not intended for harmonic distortion measurements.

If you use a fast sweep, it's also possible to window out any reflections caused by the space in which the system is installed. A drawback of doing so, however, is that a shorter measurement time will limit the frequency resolution of your measurement. A shorter measurement time will also limit the lowest frequency you can measure due to the time required for lower frequencies to resolve.

Utilizing a slower sweep and a longer Time Window will allow you to measure lower frequencies, but at the cost of letting reflections into your measurement. It is important to consider the pros and cons of each and how they correlate to which elements you're specifically interested in measuring. Averaging multiple measurements together can help reduce environmental noise and reflections, but isn't completely foolproof, either. You might be interested in measuring the response of both the system and the room together, as in nearly all cases the system will be used in a space that will also affect what the audience hears.